Jerome Jay Prather

Jerome Jay Prather

Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs

4.4 (8 reviews)
Lexington, Kentucky
22+ years experience
Garmer & Prather PLLC
Updated:

Contact Information

Opera House Building, 141 North Broadway, Lexington, KY 40507
Login to Contact

Create an account to contact this attorney

Bio

Jay Prather’s work as a trial lawyer at Garmer & Prather has earned him the recognition of his peers, including being named Best Lawyers® 2026 “Lawyer of the Year” in Plaintiffs’ Product Liability Litigation – Lexington. He continues a family tradition of Kentucky legal service and brings a disciplined, trial-focused approach to representing individuals and workers harmed by negligence, unsafe products, or wage-and-hour violations.Jay has distinguished himself through his work in state and federal courts, including successful arguments before the Kentucky Supreme Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Jay is trial-ready. He has been the lead lawyer in trial in both state and federal court in complex cases involving medical malpractice and truck collisions. He has tried cases involving wrongful death, traumatic brain cases, and many other forms of physical harm. He also serves as lead counsel in wage-and-hour class and collective actions across the Commonwealth.His peers have consistently recognized Jay’s work. In addition to the 2026 Lawyer of the Year honor, Jay has been included in Best Lawyers® for multiple years, holds an AV-Preeminent® rating from Martindale-Hubbell®, is a fellow of the Litigation Counsel of America, and appears on Super Lawyers’ “Top 50” list of outstanding lawyers in Kentucky – one of just a handful of Plaintiff’s lawyers to receive that honor.Jay is a graduate of Vanderbilt University and the University of Kentucky David J. Rosenberg College of Law. He is admitted in all state and federal courts in Kentucky, and frequently appears pro hac vice in courts outside Kentucky.Beyond his litigation practice, Jay serves as an adjunct professor teaching medical liability at the UK College of Law and remains active in many professional and community organizations in Kentucky. Among those, he is a multi-term District Vice President of the Kentucky Justice Association, which represents Plaintiff’s trial lawyers across the state, and is an elder at Crestwood Christian Church in Lexington. Jay Prather’s work as a trial lawyer at Garmer & Prather has earned him the recognition of his peers, including being named Best Lawyers® 2026 “Lawyer of the Year” in Plaintiffs’ Product Liability Litigation – Lexington. He continues a family tradition of Kentucky legal service and brings a disciplined, trial-focused approach to representing individuals and workers harmed by negligence, unsafe products, or wage-and-hour violations.Jay has distinguished himself through his work in state and federal courts, including successful arguments before the Kentucky Supreme Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Jay is trial-ready. He has been the lead lawyer in trial in both state and federal court in complex cases involving medical malpractice and truck collisions. He has tried cases involving wrongful death, traumatic brain cases, and many other forms of physical harm. He also serves as lead counsel in wage-and-hour class and collective actions across the Commonwealth.His peers have consistently recognized Jay’s work. In addition to the 2026 Lawyer of the Year honor, Jay has been included in Best Lawyers® for multiple years, holds an AV-Preeminent® rating from Martindale-Hubbell®, is a fellow of the Litigation Counsel of America, and appears on Super Lawyers’ “Top 50” list of outstanding lawyers in Kentucky – one of just a handful of Plaintiff’s lawyers to receive that honor.Jay is a graduate of Vanderbilt University and the University of Kentucky David J. Rosenberg College of Law. He is admitted in all state and federal courts in Kentucky, and frequently appears pro hac vice in courts outside Kentucky.Beyond his litigation practice, Jay serves as an adjunct professor teaching medical liability at the UK College of Law and remains active in many professional and community organizations in Kentucky. Among those, he is a multi-term District Vice President of the Kentucky Justice Association, which represents Plaintiff’s trial lawyers across the state, and is an elder at Crestwood Christian Church in Lexington. Jay has distinguished himself through his work in state and federal courts, including successful arguments before the Kentucky Supreme Court and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit. Jay is a graduate of Vanderbilt University and the University of Kentucky David J. Rosenberg College of Law. He is admitted in all state and federal courts in Kentucky, and frequently appears pro hac vice in courts outside Kentucky. Beyond his litigation practice, Jay serves as an adjunct professor teaching medical liability at the UK College of Law and remains active in many professional and community organizations in Kentucky. Among those, he is a multi-term District Vice President of the Kentucky Justice Association, which represents Plaintiff’s trial lawyers across the state, and is an elder at Crestwood Christian Church in Lexington.

Practice Areas

Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs

Awards & Recognition

  • Lawyer of the Year: Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs, Lexington (2026)
  • Lawyer of the Year: Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs, Lexington (2024)
  • Recognized: Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs

Recognized in Best Lawyers since 2023

Education

  • Vanderbilt University, B.A., graduated 2003
  • University of Kentucky, J.D., graduated 2006

Reviews

J

Jacob Bailey

3 weeks ago

Outstanding Product Liability Expert

Jay Prather’s expertise in product liability litigation was invaluable during my case. After suffering injuries from a defective product, I was overwhelmed and unsure of my legal options. Jay’s 22 years of experience and recognition as a Best Lawyers® "Lawyer of the Year" gave me confidence from the start. He meticulously reviewed the evidence, built a strong case, and fought relentlessly on my behalf. His professionalism, responsiveness, and genuine concern for my well-being set him apart. Despite the complexity of the case, Jay’s strategic approach and deep knowledge of plaintiffs’ product liability law secured a favorable outcome. I cannot recommend him highly enough—his dedication and skill truly made a difference in my life. A top-tier attorney in every sense.

K

Kenneth Wilson

3 weeks ago

Outstanding Representation in Product Liability

Jerome Jay Prather provided exceptional legal counsel during a complex product liability case. His extensive expertise, particularly in plaintiffs’ product liability litigation, was evident from the start. As a recognized Best Lawyers® “Lawyer of the Year” in this field, his sharp legal acumen and trial experience gave us confidence throughout the process. Mr. Prather’s strategic approach and meticulous attention to detail led to a favorable outcome, demonstrating his commitment to justice. His professionalism, combined with a genuinely compassionate demeanor, made a stressful situation much more manageable. I highly recommend his services to anyone seeking top-tier legal representation in product liability or general practice matters.

M

Mark Turner

3 weeks ago

Skilled Attorney with Valuable Insight

I retained Jay Prather for a complex product liability case, and his expertise was immediately apparent. His deep understanding of plaintiffs' product liability litigation, coupled with his extensive trial experience, gave me confidence in his ability to handle my case. Jay’s recognition as a Best Lawyers® “Lawyer of the Year” in this field speaks volumes about his skill, and it was evident in the way he strategized and presented my case. His knowledge of legal precedents and his ability to simplify complex legal concepts for a jury were particularly impressive. While his communication was excellent, I did notice that responses to follow-up questions sometimes took a bit longer than expected. Overall, I would highly recommend Jay Prather for anyone in need of a skilled product liability attorney who delivers strong results.

L

Lisa Cox

3 weeks ago

Trusted Advocate in Complex Cases

Jay Prather's experience in product liability litigation is truly impressive. When I faced a complex legal battle against a major corporation, his knowledge of the law and trial strategy made all the difference. He explained every step clearly, ensuring I understood the process without overwhelming me. His recognition as a 'Lawyer of the Year' in plaintiffs' product liability speaks volumes. What sets him apart is his genuine care for clients—he fought relentlessly to secure a fair settlement, and his results were outstanding. Whether it's navigating intricate legal details or providing unwavering support, Jay Prather is the kind of attorney you want by your side. Highly recommend him for any serious legal matter.

D

Donna Carter

3 weeks ago

Jay Prather: Competent Counsel with Room for Improvement

Jerome Jay Prather of Garmer & Prather PLLC in Lexington, Kentucky, has an impressive 22-year career under his belt, specializing in general practice with a notable focus on product liability litigation. As a plaintiff's attorney, Prather's expertise has earned him a Lawyer of the Year recognition in 2024 and 2026 by Best Lawyers®. While his legal skills are undoubtedly solid, my experience working with him was somewhat average. Communication, though professional, felt a bit too formal at times, leaving me yearning for a more personal touch. Wait times were acceptable but could have been more prompt during the initial stages of my case. Overall, if you're dealing with product liability issues, you're in capable hands with Jay Prather. However, if you're seeking a more communicative attorney, you may want to explore other options.

L

Lisa Davis

3 weeks ago

Excellent Product Liability Advocate

I had the opportunity to work with Jerome Jay Prather on a complex product liability case, and his expertise was evident from the start. His deep understanding of plaintiffs' product liability litigation, as recognized by Best Lawyers®, was invaluable. Jay's strategic approach and relentless preparation made a significant difference in the outcome. While his legal skills are top-tier, I found his billing structure could be more transparent. Overall, a remarkable attorney who fights hard for his clients.

G

Gary Torres

3 weeks ago

Top-Tier Legal Representation

I had the privilege of working with Jerome Jay Prather during a complex product liability case, and his expertise was nothing short of exceptional. With 22 years of experience, including recognition as a 'Lawyer of the Year' in product liability litigation, Jay brought a level of knowledge and strategy that was immediately apparent. His deep understanding of the legal nuances in my case—combined with his unwavering professionalism—ensured a favorable outcome. Jay’s ability to dissect complex legal issues and communicate them clearly made the process far less daunting. I highly recommend Garmer & Prather PLLC for anyone in need of a skilled and dedicated attorney.

D

Daniel Bailey

3 weeks ago

Skilled and dedicated litigator

I worked with Jerome Jay Prather on a complex product liability case and was impressed by his deep expertise and trial experience. His achievements, including being named Lawyer of the Year by Best Lawyers, truly reflect his dedication. He navigated our case with precision, leveraging his 22 years of experience in general practice to secure a favorable outcome. While his legal acumen is unmatched, there were occasional delays in responses, which could be streamlined. Highly recommend for anyone facing product liability or general litigation matters.

Write a Review

Please login to leave a review for this attorney.

Login to Review

Don't have an account? Create one

Related Attorneys

Larry E. Coben

Larry E. Coben

Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs

Philadelphia, PA
5.0 (1 reviews)
View Profile
Monique A. Christenson

Monique A. Christenson

Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs

Mount Pleasant, SC
5.0 (1 reviews)
View Profile
Andrew L. Andy Payne

Andrew L. Andy Payne

Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs

Dallas, TX
5.0 (1 reviews)
View Profile
AJ

Anne Joynt

Product Liability Litigation - Plaintiffs

New York, NY
5.0 (1 reviews)
View Profile