Steve A. Matthews

Adequate appellate representation with some communication delays

I hired Mr. Matthews to handle the appeal of a complex business contract dispute. His credentials from Yale and his recognition as Lawyer of the Year in Appellate Practice were certainly factors in my decision. During the briefing process, his legal analysis was thorough and his knowledge of South Carolina appellate procedure was evident. The final written brief was well-constructed and demonstrated the 15 years of experience his profile highlights. However, the experience was not without its frustrations. Communication was often slower than I expected; emails and calls would sometimes go unanswered for several days, which added to my stress during an already tense process. While the legal work product was competent, I sometimes felt like I was being managed as a case file rather than a client with pressing concerns. The outcome of my appeal was a mixed result—not a loss, but not the decisive victory I had hoped for. For someone needing solid, experienced appellate counsel in Columbia or Boston, SC, Mr. Matthews is capable, but be prepared to proactively manage the client-attorney communication aspect of your relationship.