Gerry P. Fagan

Litigation - Insurance

4.0 (1 reviews)

Billings, Montana

27+ years experience

Moulton Bellingham PC

Updated: Jan 03, 2026

Contact Information

406-248-7731

https://www.moultonbellingham.com/attorney/16/Gerry-P-Fagan

27 North 27th Street, Suite 1900, P.O. Box 2559, Billings, MT 59103-2559

Create an account to contact this attorney

Claim this profile

Are you this attorney? Claim or manage this listing by signing in or creating an attorney account.

Attorney Login Claim Profile

Bio

Gerry Fagan has been practicing as a civil litigator at one of the top Montana law firms since 1998. Gerry is a Montana native who graduated with Honors from the University of Montana School of Law. He has tried over ten jury trial cases throughout Montana, including in Billings, Missoula, and in Great Falls, Montana. He primarily handles the defense of claims for personal injury, product liability, malpractice, employment, and municipal liability. He also handles a wide range of commercial litigation claims, as well as some insurance coverage issues. He has successfully defended manufacturers of such products as cars, motorcycles, and trenching machines; oral surgeons on a state wide basis; employers against wrongful discharge suits; and many cities and towns in Montana against all manner of municipal liability claims, including claims alleging wrongful death by law enforcement officers. Gerry has also successfully handled insurance coverage declaratory judgment actions, obtaining in one matter an Order reimbursing an insurer over $350,000 in defense fees expended. He also handles larger construction disputes and represents several of the largest contractors in the Billings area. Gerry's overall litigation philosophy is to be aggressive, but in a smart and pragmatic way.

Local Legal Snapshot

Jurisdiction

Montana

State Capital

Helena

Highest Court

Montana Supreme Court

Bar Association

State Bar of Montana

Typical Consultation

$150-$300

Typical Hourly Range

$250-$450/hr

Fee Model Notes

Hourly or flat-fee billing is common.

Estimates vary by market, complexity, urgency, and attorney experience.

Practice Areas

Litigation - Insurance

Awards & Recognition

Lawyer of the Year: Litigation - Insurance, Billings (2026)
Lawyer of the Year: Litigation - Insurance, Billings (2023)
Lawyer of the Year: Personal Injury Litigation - Defendants, Billings (2022)
Lawyer of the Year: Litigation - Insurance, Billings (2019)
Lawyer of the Year: Insurance Law, Billings (2016)
Recognized: Commercial Litigation
Recognized: Government Contracts
Recognized: Insurance Law
Recognized: Litigation - Health Care
Recognized: Litigation - Insurance
Recognized: Litigation - Municipal
Recognized: Medical Malpractice Law - Defendants
Recognized: Municipal Law
Recognized: Personal Injury Litigation - Defendants
Practice Area: Government Relations Practice
Practice Area: Litigation - ERISA
Practice Area: Litigation - Labor and Employment
Practice Area: Product Liability Litigation - Defendants

Recognized in Best Lawyers since 2013

Education

The University of Montana, J.D., graduated 1998

Get Directions on Google Maps

Reviews

Mary Collins

3 months ago

A skilled and steady hand through a complex insurance dispute

I hired Gerry Fagan to represent my small business in a complicated liability insurance coverage dispute. From our first meeting, his deep knowledge of Montana insurance law was evident. He is a true Montana litigator who understands the local courts and how to navigate them effectively. His recognition as Lawyer of the Year in insurance litigation was well-earned; his strategy was meticulous and he explained every step in clear, practical terms. While his expertise is undeniable, there were a few instances where communication lagged by a day or two during less critical phases, which is my only note. His billing was fair for his 27 years of experience, though the process was complex enough that costs naturally accumulated. Ultimately, Gerry secured a very favorable settlement that protected my business. I would confidently recommend him for any serious civil litigation matter.